An Arranged Marriage ... That May Work
Patrick J. Buchanan
July 12 2004
Gephardt was the safe choice. The former minority
leader in the House would have helped Kerry in his home state, Missouri, a Red
State George W. Bush must win again in 2004.
An opponent of NAFTA and the trade deals that have caused the loss of 2.6
million manufacturing jobs, Dick Gephardt could have helped Kerry in Michigan,
Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia, where this election will be decided.
Not only do Gephardt and Kerry respect and like each other, Gephardt passes the
"heft test." No one would question his capacity to stand a heartbeat away. As
Bush has in Cheney, Kerry would have had an experienced partner in every
foreign-policy deliberation and decision.
Moreover, Gephardt has been vetted by his years in Washington and two runs for
the nomination. There was near-zero risk of a scandal exploding or a skeleton
turning up in the Gephardt closet. While he would not have added excitement to
the ticket, he would have brought strength.
But Kerry passed over his old friend for John Edwards, a man of whom he said
before the Iowa caucuses: "When I came back from Vietnam in 1969, I don't know
if John Edwards was out of diapers ..."
Ridiculing the notion of so green a rookie leading the party, Kerry added, "In
the Senate four years, and that is the full extent of public life – no
international experience, no military experience – you can imagine what the
advertising is going to be next year."
Yes, we can. Why, then, did Kerry pick this multimillionaire trial lawyer who
has never run a national media gauntlet, an unaccomplished and retiring senator
who may not be able to deliver his home state?
Answer: The Democratic Party put intense pressure on Kerry to choose Edwards,
because the party does not believe the bland Kerry has the fire or charisma to
defeat George W. Bush. A Kerry-Gephardt ticket, the party feared, would be a
This was an arranged marriage. Kerry had to do it, for the good of the family.
As the New York Times reported on the eve of the Edwards selection, "Many
prominent Democrats say they have strongly urged Mr. Kerry to choose Mr.
Edwards, and warned that he would face a battery of questions if he did not."
But if this choice does not pan out – if Edwards' disinterest and lack of depth
in foreign policy hurts the ticket, if his years as a trial lawyer hauling down
million-dollar fees become a liability, if he fails to carry his home state of
North Carolina and Kerry loses – the Edwards choice will haunt Kerry to the
grave. For one senses he did not want to do this, that it was forced upon him,
that he felt he had to do it, against his own preferences of Dick Gephardt or
his friend Sen. Bob Graham of Florida.
So it is that John Kerry has gambled his shot at the presidency on whether John
Edwards will prove the asset his advisers and the party assure him he is – but
which he himself doubts.
It is a huge gamble. Yet it may work. If Kerry-Edwards should win North Carolina
and the nation, the choice of Edwards will go down in history as inspired as the
gamble JFK took when he chose Lyndon B. Johnson, who had called his father an
appeaser of Hitler. LBJ brought Texas to the ticket and was decisive in holding
the Deep South against Nixon in that closest of all elections.
Nixon himself thought Kennedy's selection of Johnson showed both JFK's political
shrewdness and cold pragmatic streak. What does Edwards bring?
Youth, charisma, energy – and the enthusiasm of that most critical of all
Democratic constituencies, the liberal press.
And the campaign Edwards conducted, in the late primaries, where he took up the
cause of a middle class whose access ramps to the American Dream are being
closed off, is an issue on which this election could turn.
The Bush-Republican addiction to free trade, its refusal to police our borders
or cut mass immigration, is eventually going to destroy the party. Edwards,
whose home state has suffered terrible losses in the apparel and textile
industries, senses this. He came close to seizing the jobs issue from Kerry in
With factories shutting down all over America, with the new jobs being created
largely in service industries as corporate profits soar, the issue of a middle
class left behind by corporate conservatives in the West Wing could sink the
If John Edwards can make this case in the industrial heartland, he could win
this election for John Kerry. In any event, John Kerry just nervously put all
his eggs in the ability of this trial lawyer to sell the American heartland as
successfully as he used to sell those North Carolina juries.
© 2004 Creators
for printable version.
Click here for
Daily Column Archives