What's Gay Got to Do with It?
Patrick J. Buchanan
August 18 2004
"Throughout my life, I have grappled with my own identity, who I am. As
a young child, I often felt ambivalent about myself ... confused."
Thus did New Jersey Gov. James McGreevey begin his tormented press
conference wherein he outed himself as a homosexual, confessed to an
adulterous affair with another man and resigned.
"At a point in every person's life," McGreevey intoned, "one has to look
deeply into the mirror of one's soul and declare one's unique truth in
the world, not as we may want to see it or hope to see it, but as it is.
And so my truth is that I am a gay American."
McGreevey was asking us to believe that his sexual orientation, over
which he had no control, and a single "consensual" affair had forced him
to make this heroic act of renunciation of office.
Had the governor's revelation come in a vacuum, it might have been
received as the wrenching tale of a man wrestling with his sexuality and
honestly facing it. But the circumstances of McGreevey's resignation
suggest he is simply throwing a moral blanket over a smelly scandal.
"I realize the fact of this affair and my own sexuality if kept secret
leaves me, and ... the governor's office, vulnerable to rumors, false
allegations and threats of exposure," said McGreevey." But that isn't
even the half of it.
Jim McGreevey is not in a pickle because he is gay. The New Jersey press
had long heard rumors he had been out trolling as he climbed the Garden
State ladder to the governor's chair. They ignored the reports.
McGreevey's offense is that he dishonored his wife and disgraced himself
by failing to curb his appetite for other men. He is no martyr to gay
rights. He did not emerge bravely from a closet. He was dynamited out by
a 35-year-old Israeli sailor and "poet" he picked up on a junket to
Israel, imported and put on the payroll of a friendly fat cat, then on
the payroll of the taxpayers of New Jersey as homeland security czar.
McGreevey and aides say Golan Cipel was shaking down the governor for
blackmail millions with threats of a civil suit exposing their affair.
But Cipel's lawyer says the governor was forever harassing his client, a
heterosexual, for sexual favors.
Was McGreevey using his power to force Cipel to submit to his sexual
advances, or was Cipel blackmailing his older lover?
The McGreevey press conference was a pre-emptive strike to get out in
front of the filing of legal charges against him by his partner in
McGreevey's troubles began when he named the sailor-poet to head
homeland security. Cipel was an Israeli with credentials so thin the FBI
would not deal with him. At least old Wayne Hays parked Elizabeth Ray in
the typing pool. He did not try to put her on the National Security
Ousted from his homeland security post, Cipel popped up on the
governor's personal staff at $110,000 a year. New Jersey taxpayers were
thus subsidizing the secret sex life of their governor.
Even before last week, however, McGreevey was in trouble. Two of his
biggest fund-raisers had been indicted, with McGreevey's name appearing
83 times in one indictment and Cipel's name turning up in the other. The
stench of corruption from Trenton is overpowering.
But the governor still has a card to play.
"To facilitate a responsible transition," he announced offhandedly at
the close of his press conference, "my resignation will be effective on
Nov. 15." By putting it off until then, McGreevey is guaranteeing that
the new governor, his crony, senate president Richard J. Codey, will
serve out the rest of McGreevey's term, until January 2006.
Had McGreevey resigned before Sept. 3, 60 days before the presidential
election, New Jersey voters would elect a new governor on Nov. 2. By
postponing his resignation, McGreevey is cheating the people of New
Jersey of a chance to pass judgment on whether his whole crowd deserves
to be blasted out of Trenton.
Why should a governor who his disgraced his office dictate who will hold
that office for the next 18 months? Republicans are rightly demanding
that McGreevey go now.
Surely, the governor is today going through a personal hell and deserves
compassion and the support of his friends. But his conduct raises hard
questions. How can it be a natural, normal compulsion that drives a man
to take the incredible personal and political risks McGreevey took, of
seeking out secret sex with other men, when he knows that exposure means
disgrace and ruin, and the humiliation of those he purports to love?
© 2004 Creators
for printable version.
Click here for
Daily Column Archives