Why Do the Neocons Hate Dixie So?
November 26 2003
"Howard Dean wants the white trash vote," wrote Washington Post columnist
Charles Krauthammer in recent mockery of the Vermonter. "That's clearly what
[Dean] meant when he said he wanted the votes of 'guys with Confederate
flags in their pickup trucks.'"
After Dean was savaged by Al Sharpton, who called the Confederate flag an
"American swastika," Krauthammer was rhapsodic. His humiliation serves Dean
right, Krauthammer chortled. He should never have pandered to Southern
"yahoos" and "rebel-yelling racist redneck(s)."
What is it in the wiring of these neocons that they so loathe white
Southerners who cherish the monuments, men and memories of the Lost Cause?
Last December, Krauthammer, David Frum and Jonah Goldberg all squabbled
noisily over who was first to join the media mob that lynched Trent Lott for
his tribute to Sen. Thurmond on Strom's 100th birthday. When Lott lost his
leadership post, these neocons rejoiced at his resignation.
In the latest National Review – not your father's NR – an editorial calls
the cause of Southern independence, for which Gen. Robert E. Lee fought and
"Stonewall" Jackson died, the cause of "slavery and treason."
Why the Hollywood Left hates Dixie is easy to understand. It is
conservative, Christian, traditionalist, hostile to the cultural revolution.
But why do the neocons? After all, the folks Krauthammer calls "white trash"
are the most reliable conservative voters in America, God-and-country
people. They enlist in disproportionate numbers in the military, and die in
disproportionate numbers in America's wars.
The neocons are pro-Israel. So, too, are these folks who believe in standing
by Israel because the Bible tells them so. Yet, when it comes to Southerners
who revere the Confederate flag, neocons like Krauthammer echo the
Washington Post writer who dismissed Southern white Christians as "poor,
uneducated and easy to command."
But even the Post does not use the venom of Krauthammer. Indeed, I never
heard George Wallace or Lester Maddox, both of whom I came to know and like
late in their lives, use the kind of language on political foes that
Krauthammer uses on a whole class of people he doesn't even know.
A point of personal privilege. I have family roots in the South, in
Mississippi. When the Civil War came, Cyrus Baldwin enlisted and did not
survive Vicksburg. William Buchanan of Okolona, who would marry Baldwin's
daughter, fought at Atlanta and was captured by Gen. Sherman's army. William
Baldwin Buchanan was the name given to my father and by him to my late
As a member of the Sons of Confederate Veterans, I have been to their
gatherings. I spoke at the 2001 SCV convention in Lafayette, La. The
Military Order of the Stars and Bars presented me with a battle flag and a
wooden canteen like the ones my ancestors carried.
Has Krauthammer ever been to one of these meetings? Has he any knowledge at
all of these people he dismisses as "white trash"?
Discussing the Dean-flag issue, one New York Times columnist wrote of the
campaign "to remove the Stars and Bars from the top of the South Carolina
Statehouse." But it was not the Stars and Bars, first flag of the
Confederate States of America, that flew over that statehouse. It was the
battle flag of the Confederate army, with the St. Andrew's Cross, on which,
tradition holds, the apostle Andrew was crucified.
And that flag atop the statehouse flew beneath Old Glory. What were South
Carolinians saying by putting it there? Only this: "We are proud of the
bravery of our grandfathers who fought under this blood-stained banner, but
we are Americans, and the Stars and Stripes represents our country now and
forever." What is wrong with that?
To Krauthammer, the battle flag is a racist symbol. And, yes, it has been
used by racists to insult and intimidate. But so, too, has the Christian
cross when burned on hillsides. And so, too, has the American flag.
These symbols are abused because they have power. But to Southern kids who
put battle flag decals on book bags, their fathers who put replicas on cars
and trucks, rural folks who fly the flag in their yards, it does not mean
they hate anyone. Rather, it says: "We love our Southern heritage and shall
never forget our ancestors who fought and died under this flag."
Late in life, Joshua Chamberlain, the Union hero who won the Medal of Honor
for holding Little Round Top when Lee sent the Texans to turn Meade's flank
on the second day at Gettysburg, said that whenever he saw that flag, it
recalled to him the indomitable courage of the men who had fought under it.
At re-enactments of Civil War battles, high-school football games and NASCAR
races, the battle flag is ubiquitous across the South.
If Krauthammer and the neocons really believe the only folks who cherish
this symbol are "white trash" and "yahoos," that tells us more about them
than it does about the South, of which they know nothing.
© 2003 Creators
for printable version.
Click here to mail this article to a friend.
Click here for
Daily Column Archives