Israel's Isolation ... and Ours
"Israel has a right to defend itself," said President Bush. And against
whom was Israel defending itself at dawn on Monday?
A half-blind and deaf paraplegic being wheeled out of a mosque after prayers,
Sheik Ahmed Yassin was struck by missiles that blew him to pieces. In carrying
out the assassination of the founder and spiritual leader of Hamas, Ariel
Sharon used a U.S. Apache helicopter gunship. Thus, in Islamic eyes, we are
passive accomplices in the killing.
Instantly, protests erupted in Mosul and Basra. Ayatollah al-Sistani, the
Shiite leader on whom we depend for a peaceful transfer of power in Iraq, was
enraged: "[T]his morning, the occupying Zionist entity committed an ugly crime
against the Palestinian people by killing one of their heroes, scholar-martyr
Sharon's defenders say the sheik had sanctioned terror attacks on innocent
Israelis. But why did Israel not then seize him, expose his complicity in
murder, and put him in prison, as Israel had before? Why convert this crippled
old sheik into a martyr-saint? Why enhance the prestige of Hamas?
Has the killing made Israel more secure? If so, why were Israeli buses
deserted all week? Has it made us more secure? Why then were the travel
advisories issued to Americans in the Middle East? Why are U.S. embassies
shutting down? How does inflaming the Islamic world against us advance the
president's goal of persuading the world that Islam is not America's enemy?
President Bush must begin to realize that his blind solidarity with Sharon,
who has shown himself contemptuous of America's interests in the larger
region, is among the greatest crosses we have to bear in the war on terror.
A year after the fall of Baghdad, Bush's men are boasting of his triumphs –
the overthrow of the Taliban, the liberation of Iraq, not one act of terror on
U.S. soil in two years. But consider the war from bin Laden's vantage point.
The murderous strike of 9-11 electrified America-haters, but produced blowback
and near total disaster for bin Laden. In weeks, Bush had united a great
coalition, smashed the Taliban and almost finished Osama himself at Tora Bora.
Then came Iraq.
Here Bush played straight into bin Laden's hand. By attacking a prostrate Arab
nation that played no role in 9-11, we united Arab and Islamic peoples in
hatred of America. We shattered alliances and ignited a guerrilla war.
According to a Pew poll, U.S. prestige in the Muslim world has never been
lower. Bush is widely detested. In Pakistan, 65 percent of the people hold
Osama in high regard, while 8 percent are positive on Bush. We are losing the
hearts and minds of the Islamic young, creating a spawning pool out of which
future terrorists will emerge.
Now, an attack in Madrid has left 200 dead and blown a hole in our coalition.
A socialist has come to power who intends to pull Spanish troops out of Iraq.
Poland, too, has begun to waver
As Bush wins battles, Osama advances toward his strategic goals: Demonization
of America as the enemy of Islam, isolation of America as an imperialist
aggressor against Arab nations and the enabler of Sharon, and unification of
Islam's young behind bin Laden's ultimate war aim: the expulsion of America
from all Muslim lands.
The legendary Col. John Boyd described strategy as appending to oneself as
many centers of power as possible, while isolating one's enemy from as many
centers of power as possible.
Bush I did this brilliantly in the Gulf War, isolating Saddam. Bush II did it
brilliantly in the Afghan war, isolating the Taliban. Now Bush has fallen into
the trap his father avoided. He is letting Ariel Sharon create the perception
that America's war and Israel's war are one and the same.
In the Middle East, Sharon has no friends. He does not care whom he alienates.
But we are a world power with friend, allies and interests in 22 Arab and 57
To protect our interests, to win our war on al-Qaida, it is imperative that we
not let ourselves become as isolated as Israel is today.
Between America and Israel, there are thus common interests and a collision of
interests. Sharon does not want us to confine our war on terror to those who
attacked us on 9-11. He wants us to expand our list of enemies to include his
list of enemies: Arafat, Hamas, Hezbollah, Syria, Iran, Saudi Arabia. He wants
us to escalate "the firemen's war" into an American war on Israel's enemies,
so, together, we can establish joint hegemony in the Middle East.
If Sharon and his acolytes in the Bush administration succeed in conflating
Sharon's war with America's war, we could lose our war. Why cannot the
president see what is going on?
© 2004 Creators
for printable version.
Click here to mail this article to a friend.
Click here for
Daily Column Archives