Whose War Is This?
By Patrick J. Buchanan
September 28, 2001
In his resolve to hunt down and kill the Osama bin Laden
terrorists he says committed the Sept. 11 massacres, President Bush has
behind him a nation more unified than it has been since Pearl Harbor. But
now Bush has been put on notice that this war cannot end with the head of
bin Laden and the overthrow of the Taliban.
The shot across Bush's bow came in an "Open Letter"
co-signed by 41 foreign-policy scholars, including William Bennett, Jeane
Kirkpatrick, the publisher of The Weekly Standard and the
editor in chief of The New Republic — essentially, the
entire neoconservative establishment.
What must Bush do to retain their support? Target Hezbollah
for destruction and retaliate against Syria and Iran if they refuse to cut
all ties to Hezbollah and move militarily to overthrow Iraq's Saddam
Hussein. Failure to attack Iraq, the neocons warn Bush, "will consti
"Our purpose in writing is to assure you of our support
as you do what must be done to lead the nation to victory in this
fight," the letter ends.
Implied is a threat to end support if Bush does not widen the
war to include all of Israel's enemies, or if he pursues the
U.S.-Arab-Muslim coalition of Secretary of State Colin Powell. Among the
signers is Richard Perle, chairman of Bush's own Defense Policy Board, a
key advisory group.
This letter represents one side of a brutal policy battle
that has erupted in the capital: Is it to be Powell's war or Perle's war?
A critical decision
The final decision Bush makes will be as historically crucial
as Truman's decision to let MacArthur advance to the Yalu, and FDR's
decision to hold up Eisenhower's armies and let Stalin take Berlin.
How the president will come down is unknown.
In his address to Congress a week ago, Bush declared:
"From this day forward, any nation that continues to harbor or
support terrorism will be regarded by the United States as a hostile
regime." The president seemed to be offering amnesty, or conditional
absolution, to rogue states if they enlist in America's war, now, and
expel all terrorist cells.
Even Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld is signaling that what
matters is not where nations stood, but where they stand. On Sunday, he
said on CBS: "What we are looking at today is how are these states
going to behave going forward."
And Powell's coalition is coming together. Whether out of
fear or opportunism, Libya, Syria, Iran and the Palestinian Authority have
all denounced the atrocities of Sept. 11. Pakistan has joined the
coalition. Sudan is cooperating.
But calls for a wider war dominate the neoconservative media.
The Weekly Standard's opinion editor, David Tell, wants war
not only on past sponsors of terror, but also on "any group or
government inclined to support or sustain others like them in the
Bennett wants Congress to declare war on "militant
Islam" and "overwhelming force" used on state sponsors of
terror such as Lebanon, Libya, Syria, Iraq, Iran and even China. The
Wall Street Journal wants strikes "aimed at terrorist camps in
Syria, Sudan, Libya and Algeria, and perhaps even in parts of Egypt."
On their lists
Terrorism expert Steve Emerson puts Lebanon's Bekaa Valley at
the top of his list. Benjamin Netanyahu includes in the "Empire of
Terror" to be obliterated: Hamas, Hezbollah, "the Palestinian
enclave," as well as Iran, Iraq and Taliban Afghanistan. Tom Donnelly
and Gary Schmitt of the Project for the New American Century want Iraq
invaded now: "Nor need the attack await the deployment of half a
million troops. ... The larger challenge will be occupying Iraq after the
fighting is over."
As of now, Bush is laser-focused on bin Laden and the
But when that war is over, the great policy battle will be decided: Do we
then dynamite Powell's U.S.-Arab-Muslim coalition by using U.S. power to
invade Iraq? Do we then reverse alliances and make Israel's war America's
Allies would be at risk
If the United States invades Iraq, bombs Hezbollah and
conducts strikes on Syria and Iran, this war will metastasize into a
two-continent war from Algeria to Afghanistan, with the United States and
Israel alone against a half-dozen Arab and Muslim states. The first
casualties would be the moderate Arabs — Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia,
the Gulf states — who were our Cold War and Gulf War allies.
The war Netanyahu and the neo
Back to Home Page